Feb. 8, 1999
Open letter to the hacking community:
Last week, Steve Silberman of Wired News called to tell me he and I and
some other journalists had been duped by a psuedo-hacker named Christian
Valor, AKA se7en. In April 1998, I"d posted a piece on the Forbes Digital
Tool web site about Valor"s kiddie porn vigilantism and the fact that law
enforcement knew what he was doing, but turned a blind eye. Cool story.
Too bad it turned out not to be true.
I was certainly in good company. Steve also had written about Valor"s
exploits, as had Newsday, the Independent in London, etc. Both Steve and
I
received letters from se7en's ex-girlfriend simultaneously last week, but
Steve got on to the story first. I was out of town. Sad to say, he and I
were the only ones to respond to her letter. I told Steve I wouldn't post
anything until his story hit. (See "Kid-Porn Vigilante Hacked Media
http://www.wired.com/news/news/culture/story/17775.html).
I can't comment on how the Steve or the Independent or Newsday conducted
their research, but I would like to share with all of you how I did mine,
and what went wrong. I"m sure there are lessons to be learned.
As you may or may not know, I am no stranger to taking on journalists I
think have concocted stories out of thin air. I broke the Stephen Glass
story, the associate editor of The New Republic who made up a story on
hackers and was later discovered to have made up some three dozen stories
for a number of well-known publications (See "Lies, damn lies and
fiction": http://www.forbes.com/tool/html/98/may/0511/otw3.htm). I also
took on Beth Piskora of The New York Post, who I believe made up a sexy
tech story on Organized Crime setting up phony companies for Y2K
remediation, who then, she claims, inserted software to divert money from
bank accounts (read: clients) to mob-controlled accounts. (See "Phantom
mobsters": http://www.forbes.com/tool/html/98/aug/0828/feat.htm). This
canard was picked up by Vanity Fair in a recent feature on Y2K. Vanity
Fair has yet to admit it published a lie.
I hate it when you nail a journalist and instead of coming clean, he or
she hides. This is what both Glass and Piskora have done. That's why I"m
writing this note.
For my story (Kiddie porn vigilante:
http://www.forbes.com/tool/html/98/apr/0417/feat.htm) I knew I couldn"t
get on IRC and traffic in kiddie porn on a Forbes computer. You remember
what happened to that journalist for NPR who did, and is now had to plead
guilty to a felony all because he was ostensibly researching a story? So
I
relied on law enforcement, EHAP, and NAMBLA. I called literally 10 law
enforcement officials who said they studied under Valor in one of his
security courses. On the record, they would all vouch for se7en"s hacking
skills. Off the record, they all said they knew what he was doing but
they
didn't care. Everyone hates kiddie porn traffickers.
I also talked to EHAP, and they told me they were distressed by se7en"s
actions, because it gave hackers a bad name. Se7en should turn them over
to the cops or the ISPs, they said, not break the law in going after
them.
They didn"t say he was a fraud.
I also contacted NAMBLA through its web site. I asked if anyone knew a
hacker named se7en, who was purportedly going after kiddie porn
traffickers on IRC. I received a cryptic response, something along the
lines of, "Yes, some of our members have been complaining about this guy.
We just want to be left alone." End of conversation. He refused to turn
over any other details.
So I felt confident that with all this cross-checking that Valor was who
he said he was. Obviously, I made a mistake. I think the most important
lesson I learned is that law enforcement doesn"t have a clue what really
goes on in hacking circles; they are not good sources for this. I also
now
won"t write a hacking story unless I can meet the hacker face-to-face and
actually see evidence that I can then verify with other hackers/or
computer security experts I trust. This is how I approached my story for
Forbes magazine on the NY Times hack that ran last fall (available online
at: (http://www.forbes.com/forbes/98/1116/6211132a.htm).
If you want to send me taunting email, telling me what a fool I was, feel
free. I"m at apenenberg@forbes.com. But you can"t possibly be harder on
me
than I"ve been on myself this past week. You live, you learn.
Sincerely,
Adam Penenberg
Senior Editor, Forbes Magazine
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 8 of 54: wer (KitchenManager) * Thu, Feb 11, 1999 (18:56) * 1 lines
excellent piece
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 9 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Fri, Feb 12, 1999 (15:26) * 2 lines
That was good.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 10 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Mon, Mar 8, 1999 (15:07) * 23 lines
Bruce's party:
PARTY INVITATION. In totally informal conjunction with
the annual South By SouthWest Multimedia Festival, my wife
Nancy and I are throwing another Open House Party on the
evening of March 16th, Tuesday, starting, say, 7:30 pm or
so. If you're in Dead Media Project, please consider this
your formal invitation to attend. Bring anybody you
trust. There will be cold beer. And (even more
astonishing and provocative) there will be cigarettes.
If you've never been to my house before (once memorably
described by TIME magazine as "the leafy tranquillity of
Sterling's well-appointed Austin, Texas home"), send email
and I'll ship you the directions and a phone number.
Mind you, the SXSW Multimedia Party we threw last time was
not half shabby. These digital-arts people are
definitely a self-starting crowd. No Charades or Twister
was required to break the ice. Quite a good time was had
by all.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 11 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Thu, Jul 1, 1999 (13:23) * 15 lines
There's a good article about writers lairs today in XL, where they
describe their environments, their habits and distractions. Anyone who's
been to a Bruce Sterling fete has probably meandered down the hall to his
home office and Bruce is one of the interviewees. Along with novelist
Sarah Bird, Robert Draper, Milly Ivins, screenwriter Bill Witliff
(Lonesome Dove), and playwright Jo Carol Pierce. I like Bruces quote on
Austin clothing style "it's not just that people here dress like slobs,
they dress aggressively like slobs" in response to the query on
"inspirational clothing."
Bill Witliff writes in O'Henry's old house.
(reference July 1 99 XLent)
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 12 of 54: Alexander Schuth (aschuth) * Thu, Jul 1, 1999 (13:53) * 3 lines
Terry, have you read Bruce's last book, Distraction ? He got off on the dress subject there big time...
So, do Austinites have a bad sense of dressing?
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 13 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Thu, Jul 1, 1999 (14:05) * 9 lines
I dress for total comfort, every day, even when I'm consulting at IBM.
Bruce is right. Austin is a total slacker dress environment. Lately,
I've been wearing either jeans and a free t shirt (one of many of
gotten at computer trade shows) or Columbia pants and shirts (Columbia
clothes are for total comfort, the pants are these zip apart
convert-to-swim trunks lightweight material and the shirts make you look
like you're either a photographer or on an expedition.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 14 of 54: Alexander Schuth (aschuth) * Thu, Jul 1, 1999 (14:30) * 1 lines
Ho! The adventurous look!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 15 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Thu, Jul 1, 1999 (17:45) * 5 lines
Yep, more the comfort look. I wear the most comfortable clothes I can
find. There are no dress codes at places of work in Austin, just about
anything goes. The only place I go that has a dress code is the Sports
Club (no tank tops or skin tight shorts, which I don't wear anyway).
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 16 of 54: Alexander Schuth (aschuth) * Mon, Jul 5, 1999 (06:29) * 1 lines
No shirt No shoes No Dice ?
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 17 of 54: wer (KitchenManager) * Tue, Jul 6, 1999 (01:25) * 2 lines
You talkin' to me?
(or is that just a friendly proposition?)
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 18 of 54: Alexander Schuth (aschuth) * Thu, Jul 8, 1999 (07:22) * 1 lines
So, you a sloppy (err, sorry, mark that: comfortable) dresser, too?
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 19 of 54: wer (KitchenManager) * Fri, Jul 9, 1999 (03:52) * 2 lines
most of the time...depends on the occasion...when
I temped at the State, I wore a tie every day...
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 20 of 54: Stacey Vura (stacey) * Fri, Jul 9, 1999 (12:17) * 2 lines
woo woo!
i wanna see that!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 21 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Fri, Jul 9, 1999 (13:06) * 2 lines
I can't remember the last time I wore a tie.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 22 of 54: Stacey Vura (stacey) * Fri, Jul 9, 1999 (14:47) * 1 lines
probably somewhere between bee pollen gathering and MagRabbiteering...
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 23 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Sun, Jul 11, 1999 (04:27) * 1 lines
I used to wear a tie at BPI, back in 1985.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 24 of 54: casanova (casanova) * Sun, Jul 11, 1999 (11:01) * 1 lines
is that a choice to shose betwwen a tie and t_shirt
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 25 of 54: wer (KitchenManager) * Sun, Jul 11, 1999 (11:27) * 3 lines
good question!
Good morning, Casanova, how are you today?
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 26 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (18:19) * 4 lines
I devoutly hope there is an especially nasty place in the afterlife for those who hack into private information and use it as a threat to ruin lives. I have twice been the victim of this reprehensible activity and I would happily watch some malicious endeavor enacted on those who requested it and for those who did it. My deepest loathing is reserved for them.
I am happy you are comfortable in Austin...we dress like that out here, as well.
However, I will do just about anything for a man considerate enough to wear a tie for me. There have been none in my life in the last 20 years...perhaps I am not worth the effort...
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 27 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (18:56) * 1 lines
Hear, hear! That's as tasteless and outright wrong as snooping through someone's personal effects. I'm sure computer hackers are the same people who come to your house, go to the bathroom, and look through your medicine cabinet, helping themselves to whatever they think they might need!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 28 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (19:47) * 1 lines
...or whatever they can hold you hostage to return while keeping just enough for them selves that you are never free of the scumbags (the most polite term I can think of at the moment). Thanks, Amy!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 29 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (20:54) * 8 lines
I just think men are getting away from constrictive ties and we're moving
to a more casual dress code. It may not be disrespect or lack of
attentiveness to you. Not having to wear a tie to work is becoming a sign
of indendence and freedom, especially in the high tech startups. And I
can also see where if it made you happy that a guy with you would want to
wear a tie just to make you feel good. If that's what does it for you!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 30 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (21:06) * 1 lines
I like ties on men, as long as they're not too short or have gravy dribbled down the front! I know I prefer myself dressed up, and so I also prefer men dressed up. Rebelling against my redneck, "wearing a shirt without holes in it is dressed up" childhood, I guess!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 31 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (21:53) * 1 lines
Terry, is it really too much to expect when I am attired in the best I have to wear as he wishes to show me off as his jewel, that he dress accordingly? No matter whether it is to a symphony concert or an academic reception - he dresses the same - aloha shirt, which is appropriate for just about anything BUT a formal setting. Just once in a while...maybe even just once a year...but some time in the 15+ years he has been around!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 32 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (21:54) * 1 lines
...and, yes! That REALLY does it for me...!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 33 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (21:58) * 1 lines
Ah, some men are hopeless--my dad didn't even wear a tie to my college graduation!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 34 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (22:11) * 1 lines
Well, someone suggested I bury him in one. Heck no! If he won't put it on, I sure am not going to do it for him. What good is it anyway when he is dead?!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 35 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Fri, Oct 29, 1999 (22:33) * 1 lines
He'd probably come back and haunt you if you did! *giggle*
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 36 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Sat, Oct 30, 1999 (00:29) * 1 lines
Probably...just to be irritating...! *lol*
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 37 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Sat, Oct 30, 1999 (05:31) * 3 lines
Oh sure, if you get that dudded up he should wear a tie. Ties are really
going away as work attire. It would probably put you at a disadvantage to
show up for an interview with a tech company in Austin wearing a tie.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 38 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Sat, Oct 30, 1999 (13:12) * 1 lines
I understand that. Same with geology jobs in California. A neat sports shirt and tailored slacks is fine unless they are meeting in the field, in which case it is hiking boots, jeans and appropriate shirt. I even like turtleneck and sports jacket for evening, but...maybe in another life time I'll get one who understands what is appropriate dress for special occasions.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 39 of 54: Isabel (Isabel) * Mon, Nov 1, 1999 (10:10) * 1 lines
Maybe you should tell him that he looks more distinguished, impressive or authoritarian in a tuxedo - this may help if he loves pedestals so much as you mentioned before...( or that it makes him look ten years younger and is impressing the girls °grin°)
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 40 of 54: Alexander (aschuth) * Mon, Nov 1, 1999 (12:12) * 1 lines
(hehe)
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 41 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Mon, Nov 1, 1999 (14:19) * 2 lines
Tuxedos? You gotta be kidding...though his vanity might be nudged by the idea of enticing girls with a tie. Perhaps his tielessness is just another mark against him as I weigh the pros and cons of his continued existance in my world.
Pathetically, the man is clueless even when I draw him a picture - he just tells me to go take something and to calm down. I will die of pill poisioning soon!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 42 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Mon, Nov 1, 1999 (14:20) * 3 lines
However, the next guy I see who is wearing one, I am ripping open my bodice and letting him have his way with me...
(sounds good but I could never go through with it..)
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 43 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Mon, Nov 1, 1999 (17:07) * 1 lines
*snicker*
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 44 of 54: Isabel (Isabel) * Tue, Nov 2, 1999 (11:07) * 1 lines
Why not? :-D
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 45 of 54: Fit to be "tied" in Hilo (MarciaH) * Tue, Nov 2, 1999 (11:54) * 1 lines
...'cause I am basically chicken... but it does sound like such a good idea. They are very few and far between out here in the humidity and heat. Perhaps I should just settle for academic regalia...with the tie and dress shirt beneath, but I did that once, and clothes did NOT make the man...and if it were not for hackers I just might know what ones looks like who is especially choice anyway by now.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 46 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Tue, Nov 2, 1999 (13:45) * 3 lines
Hmm...I wonder...
Who is Bruce Sterling, anyhow? It reminds me of Remington Steele.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 47 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Tue, Nov 2, 1999 (14:04) * 1 lines
Beats me - Bruce Willis-Rod Serling cross? Terry will know, though! (If you read the intro to this topic (up there before the first post) it will tell you more about this man.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 48 of 54: Alexander (aschuth) * Tue, Nov 2, 1999 (15:40) * 5 lines
Bruce Sterling, journalist and established novelist, Austin. Two kids, married. Will found ecological movement "Viridianism" on Jan 3rd 2000.
See topic on Viridianism in Environment conf, and the Dead Media topic - another pet subject of his - in Media.
Best known as co-founder of the cyberpunk-genre in Sci-Fi (along with William Gibson and others), he wrote his Hacker Crackdown after Austin's Steve Jackson Games have been raided by justice forces. This book describes all that lead to the raid, the whole hacker-scenes, certain cases. The important part is, the book was very early (1991 or 92), and showed the side of the hackers, telcos, police and federal agents. Entirely non-fictional, and good to read.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 49 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Nov 5, 1999 (16:09) * 1 lines
If there were any lawsuits involved perhaps I can take notes. I am going to personally emasculate the guy who has caused me so much grief in this area and hit him where he thinks he lives...(anger and indignation unabated and not forgiven nor forgotten!)
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 50 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Fri, Nov 5, 1999 (17:35) * 1 lines
Go get 'em, Marcia!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 51 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Nov 5, 1999 (18:23) * 1 lines
...froth...froth...! Hope they do not have rabies injections. I need all of this anger to work for me when I kick the miserable man out of my life!
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 52 of 54: Marcia (MarciaH) * Fri, Nov 5, 1999 (18:25) * 1 lines
I am a nice lady, actually...but I have been pushed too far for too long, and this time the enormous rug rat in the other room has overstepped his bounds.
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 53 of 54: Amy Keene (Irishprincess) * Fri, Nov 5, 1999 (19:33) * 1 lines
Kick him to the curb! (Just kidding--I was pretending I was on a talk show.)
Topic 25 of 44 [internet]: hackers (Hacker Crackdown by Bruce Sterling)
Response 54 of 54: Paul Terry Walhus (terry) * Thu, Dec 8, 2005 (00:05) * 2 lines
http://www.hackaday.com/



internet conference
Main Menu